News
Hotel McArthur historic renovation to continue thanks to $5 million in new grant funds
By: Amanda Pirani
Posted on:
MCARTHUR, Ohio (WOUB/Report for America) — After a fire caused severe damage to Hotel McArthur in July, the historic building is now back on track for a renovation.

Audie Games, president of the visitors bureau, said the group sought congressional support for the project last year. But it wasn’t until the end of January the organization learned Sen. Jon Husted secured federal funding for the hotel’s restoration.
The project is also expecting to receive a state brownfield remediation grant this month, which will fund debris clean up from the fire and any necessary structure stabilization.
Before the fire, the visitors bureau secured two state grants for the hotel’s restoration. The organization was granted extensions on using the grants to see if it could obtain the necessary funding to move forward.
Games said the project’s architect is still developing a firm timeline, but ideally, construction will begin this summer. In the meantime, the hotel property will undergo environmental assessments this spring as required by the grant funding.
Ultimately, the visitors bureau plans to restore the structure to once again serve as a hotel for tourists visiting the area. It will also include a visitors bureau office.
Tiffany Cline, visitors bureau vice president, said some of the structure will have to be rebuilt, but the goal is to preserve key elements such as the front lobby’s wooden staircase.
Tourism is a growing sector of Vinton County’s economy. In addition to a growing number of local festivals, the Lake Hope and Zaleski State Forest areas draw in visitors for camping and outdoor recreation.
Cline said right now, the county has few lodging options outside of Airbnb, so she hopes the hotel can offer something new.
“Why wouldn’t we want to create accommodations for those people coming here, and maybe even a cheaper accommodation as well?” she asked.
She added that many people in the community have ties to the hotel and its history who are eager to see it restored.
Linda Tripp Crager, who grew up in Vinton County, drove over an hour from Canal Winchester to learn what would become of the hotel at a visitors bureau meeting.
“It’s been on my heart because we were born and raised and went to high school here,” she said. “My heart has always been fond of McArthur and I am just so excited about a new hotel.”
Crager said her family has a long history in the county, and her mother worked in the hotel in the 1940s.
Hotel restoration on track after series of setbacks
The hotel’s future remained uncertain for the last two years, as the visitors bureau navigated a separation from the county and the aftermath of the fire.
The visitors bureau purchased the hotel from a private owner in 2021, with plans to remove modern additions and restore it to the original 19th century design.
Then, in 2024, the county prosecutor and commissioners requested the entire bureau staff resign, citing concerns with financial irregularities and alleged mismanagement. Those in leadership at the time are no longer working with the CVB.
The commissioners later created a new county division of tourism, known as Discover Vinton County.
CVB members Games, Cline and Sharon Connor said they were never provided a specific reason as to why they should resign and refused to do so. While the organization maintained ownership of the McArthur Hotel, it lost the bed tax that funded most of its operations, which now goes to Discover Vinton County.
Since then, the three women have continued to run the organization for the last two years as unpaid volunteers while working full time.
Without the bed tax income, there was some concern that the visitors bureau would be unable to pay the mortgage on the hotel or address the damage caused by the fire.
But Games said the insurance from the fire has now been fully paid out, allowing the organization to purchase the property outright.
“It’s validating, that it’s all going through,” Cline said. “We’re still pushing on because this will be really good for McArthur and Vinton County.”
Amanda Pirani is WOUB’s Report for America Journalist covering Economic Livelihood. For more information about Report for America, you can click here.
