Nelsonville faces a new lawsuit over the rightful city government
By: Haley Richardson
Posted on:
ATHENS, Ohio (WOUB) — An elected auditor is suing Nelsonville again in a new lawsuit challenging the legal authority of one of its two rival governments.

The previous council operates under Nelsonville’s charter, a legal document dictating the city’s policies and procedures. The new council operates under Issue 23, a citizen-led ballot initiative voters passed in November 2024 that would abolish the city’s charter and establish a new government with an independently elected mayor and partisan council.
However, the charter council repealed Issue 23 in August, citing the lack of a transition plan. Since then, there have been multiple legal actions concerning the legitimacy of candidates who ran under Issue 23 and the validity of the repeal.
Attorney Daniel Klos represents Andrea Thompson Hashman, who was elected city auditor under Issue 23. He also represented her in a similar lawsuit filed in September asking an Athens County judge to declare the repeal invalid, but the case was dismissed because the judge said Thompson Hashman had not yet been legally harmed by the repeal — she was on the ballot and was elected.
In the new lawsuit filed in the Athens County Court of Common Pleas on Wednesday, Klos once again argues the council’s repeal of Issue 23 was invalid and violated Thompson Hashman’s rights as both a voter who supported Issue 23 and as an elected official who has been denied her office. Klos emphasized Nelsonville’s voters’ rights to choose their own form of government, a right he said was exercised by the 70% of people who voted in favor of Issue 23 in 2024.
The charter council maintains it has the right under the charter to repeal citizen initiatives, and so the charter is still in effect.
Even assuming that’s true, Klos argues his client and the others elected to office in November are still the legitimate city officials.
Klos raises this as an alternative argument in the new lawsuit. The November ballot did not specify which candidates were running for a statutory or charter council, he argues, only listing them as “council at large” positions with the start dates for each term.
On the ballot, seven people ran for terms starting Jan. 1, which is when the new government would have taken over under Issue 23: Glenn Smith, Lynn Bishop, Jessica Hollenbaugh, Nic Joseph Saul, McCray Powell, Sue Powell and Wesley Henderson. The Athens County Board of Elections certified their election wins.
Four people ran for a one-month term in December, created to bridge the gap under Issue 23 between the end of the charter council terms on Nov. 30 and the start of the new government on Jan. 1. Those four were Nic Joseph Saul, Cameron Peck, McCray Powell and Cory Taylor. They then appointed former council members Gregg Clement and Nancy Sonick and local business owner Amy Hollenbaugh to fill the remaining vacancies. Except for Taylor, the remaining six members have stayed on council past Dec. 31 and appointed Charlotte Beach to fill the empty seat.
Klos claims that none of these positions are valid, as they do not have election certificates for a term beyond Dec. 31, meaning that the seven candidates elected to a term starting Jan. 1 have the legal authority to hold office.
This argument is consistent with actions taken at the first meeting of the council established Jan. 1. The members called themselves to order as the legitimate charter council and then voted to overturn the repeal of Issue 23, which they believe means Issue 23 is back in effect, the charter is abolished and they will now meet as the new government established under Issue 23 moving forward.
Joseph Saul and McCray Powell did not take their seats on that council even though they were also elected to Jan. 1 terms. Because they remain on the rival council — the one that continues to operate under the charter — Klos argues their seats on that council are invalid because they do not have election certificates for those seats.
Dinsmore and Shohl, the law firm representing the council operating under the charter, declined to comment on the lawsuit.
